Sold
16 Abbey Lane East Setauket, NY 11733
$1,350,000
Listed at $1,399,999. Closed August 18, 2026.
Listing courtesy of Renee M. Milani CBR, Douglas Elliman Real Estate MLS #KEY872010
Only the front exterior photograph is shown on closed sales, in keeping with OneKey MLS rules.
- 6Bedrooms
- 4.5Bathrooms
- 4,500Square feet
- $300Per square foot
- 1984Year built
About this home
A rare opportunity offering true versatility—this beautifully maintained Colonial in East Setauket features a legal, owner-occupied accessory apartment, creating the perfect “two homes in one” setup. Ideal for extended family, guests, or additional income, the private two-bedroom, townhouse-style apartment includes its own entrance, separate deck, modern open layout, and a spa-like bathroom with a soaking tub. Designed for both comfort and independence, it’s a standout feature of this exceptional property. The main residence is equally impressive. A welcoming wrap-around porch sets the tone, perfect for morning coffee or hosting guests. Inside, a spacious great room with a fireplace flows seamlessly into a professionally landscaped backyard, complete with an in-ground sprinkler system and a tranquil koi pond—your own private retreat. Additional highlights include an extended driveway accommodating multiple vehicles, owned solar panels for energy efficiency, two separate attics, and abundant storage throughout. The fully finished walk-out basement offers valuable additional living space, ideal for a recreational area, home gym, or media room. With direct outdoor access, it provides flexibility for entertaining, extended living, or creating a private retreat. With a total of six bedrooms and 4.5 bathrooms, this home offers ample space for a variety of living arrangements. Whether you’re seeking multi-generational living or the benefit of rental income, this property delivers unmatched flexibility and value. Located in the Three Village School District and close to beaches, hospitals, and universities, this is a unique offering you won’t want to miss!
Description supplied by the listing broker.
Features
- Built-in Features
- Ceiling Fan(s)
- Chandelier
- Eat-in Kitchen
- Granite Counters
- High Ceilings
- His and Hers Closets
- In-Law Floorplan
- Primary Bathroom
- Open Floorplan
- Open Kitchen
- Original Details
- Recessed Lighting
- Soaking Tub
This listing
- August 18, 2026 Sold for $1,350,000
- June 1, 2025 Listed at $1,399,999
Location
16 Abbey Lane, East Setauket, NY 11733
Nearby recent sales
0.7 mi
$3,400,000
2 Pheasant RunSetauket
5 Beds · 6.5 Baths · 6,326 Sq.Ft.
Listing courtesy of Tor F. Johnson, Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
0.7 mi
$1,800,000
2 Pheasant RunOld Field
5 Beds · 6.5 Baths
Listing courtesy of Lynn J. Sabatelle, Daniel Gale Agency Inc
1.0 mi
$9,500,000
25 Brewster LaneEast Setauket
6 Beds · 8.5 Baths · 20,000 Sq.Ft.
Listing courtesy of John P. Vitello, Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons
1.0 mi
$2,500,000
25 Brewster LaneSetauket
4 Beds · 4 Baths · 3,311 Sq.Ft.
Listing courtesy of Ann S. Strong, Daniel Gale Agency Inc
1.3 mi
$2,050,000
457 Pond PathEast Setauket
4 Beds · 3 Baths
Listing courtesy of Michelle Madtes, BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY
1.3 mi
$1,975,000
73 Shore RoadSetauket
6 Beds · 5.5 Baths · 5,300 Sq.Ft.
Listing courtesy of Miriam Ainbinder, Daniel Gale Agency Inc