Sold
457 Pond Path East Setauket, NY 11733
$2,050,000
Listed at $2,500,000. Closed November 14, 2025.
Listing courtesy of Michelle Madtes, BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY MLS #KEYL3587595
Only the front exterior photograph is shown on closed sales, in keeping with OneKey MLS rules.
- 4Bedrooms
- 3Bathrooms
- 1958Year built
About this home
A rare opportunity awaits in the Three Village school district in East Setauket! Presenting for the first time ever on the market, this unique offering features 4.88 acres of prime East Setauket real estate. Located on Pond Path between Nesconset Highway and Saint Georges golf and country club, this property provides the perfect location and with a blend of both convenience and privacy. The sale includes two adjoining parcels: a charming 0.95-acre lot with a solid ranch-style home, and an expansive 3.93-acre lot with endless potential. The ranch has great bones with a spacious layout including an eat-in kitchen, dining room, living room, and also a family room with a fireplace and bar in the lower level. It also features a spacious primary bedroom with an Ensuite bathroom and 3 other good sized bedrooms. Original white oak floors add character throughout, includes central air and central vac, 3 heat zones, while ample storage and a large laundry room ensures practicality. Though some great updates have been made, this well taken care of home is in need of updating. This home offers a wonderful canvas to create your dream space. A must see in person to truly appreciate it. The additional 3.93 acres of land open up a world of possibilities-ideal for equestrians, builders, gardening enthusiasts, or anyone who cherishes nature and space. The property enjoys a serene setting, bordered by a property (which cannot develop within 50 feet) on one side and state-owned land on the other, ensuring both privacy and tranquility. The taxes on both lots combined are $20,953. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a versatile and expansive property in the beautiful community of East Setauket.
Description supplied by the listing broker.
Features
- Built-in Features
- Eat-in Kitchen
- Entrance Foyer
- Master Downstairs
- Formal Dining
- First Floor Bedroom
- Primary Bathroom
This listing
- November 14, 2025 Sold for $2,050,000
- October 25, 2024 Listed at $2,500,000
Location
457 Pond Path, East Setauket, NY 11733
Nearby recent sales
0.2 mi
$1,210,000
9 Clemens CourtSetauket
4 Beds · 3.5 Baths
Listing courtesy of Zachary Scher CBR, Signature Premier Properties
0.2 mi
$1,375,000
10 Clemens CourtEast Setauket
4 Beds · 3.5 Baths · 3,134 Sq.Ft.
Listing courtesy of Himilce M. Petsco, Jolie Powell Realty Inc
0.2 mi
$1,325,000
5 Clemens CourtEast Setauket
4 Beds · 2.5 Baths · 3,181 Sq.Ft.
Listing courtesy of Holly B. Brainard MRP, Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
0.4 mi
$1,400,000
50 Cobbler LaneSetauket
5 Beds · 2.5 Baths · 3,500 Sq.Ft.
Listing courtesy of Kristin A. Bodkin, Howard Hanna Coach
0.4 mi
$1,175,000
48 Cobbler LaneSetauket
6 Beds · 3 Baths · 4,083 Sq.Ft.
Listing courtesy of Rosanne D'Agostino, Douglas Elliman Real Estate
0.5 mi
$1,280,000
9 Huckleberry LaneEast Setauket
4 Beds · 3.5 Baths · 3,800 Sq.Ft.
Listing courtesy of Crystal Condos, Exit Realty Achieve